What if the two Liberty silver dollars recovered from the former Ashley Gang site were never meant to be spent? Expedition Unknown follows Josh Gates into the remains of a notorious Prohibition-era operation where two ordinary-looking coins may be anything but ordinary. Their dates fit the gang’s active years perfectly—and if they were deliberately buried as markers, the discovery may point to something far more valuable still missing beneath the Florida soil.
Two Silver Dollars Appear From the Gang’s Lost World
At first, two Liberty silver dollars seem almost insignificant compared with the larger story surrounding the Ashley Gang. Yet their dates—between 1921 and 1928—place them directly inside the period when the notorious gang was active and its whiskey operation reportedly produced more than 100 gallons a day. That places the coins in exactly the right historical window, turning what might look like loose change into physical evidence connected to the world the gang built around illicit alcohol and hidden money.

For Expedition Unknown, the real intrigue begins when the coins are considered alongside the scale of the operation. If enormous quantities of whiskey and cash were moving through the property, why have only two silver dollars survived underground? A few coins could easily have been dropped and forgotten, but their scarcity creates a more provocative possibility. Perhaps these were never simply pieces of spending money. Perhaps they were placed there for a reason.
The soil may have preserved only two small clues from a much larger financial operation, leaving Josh Gates with a question far bigger than the value of the coins themselves: what happened to the money that should have been moving through this site?
The Coins May Have Been Markers, Not Money
The most intriguing theory is that the silver dollars were deliberately positioned to identify something hidden nearby. A marker would explain why only a tiny number of coins survived from an operation that allegedly handled enormous amounts of money. Instead of representing a transaction, they could have functioned as a coded signpost—a simple object that gang members would recognize but outsiders would dismiss as worthless debris.

That possibility becomes even more compelling when the January 9, 1924 raid enters the story. If the gang knew authorities were closing in, they may have had little time to protect emergency cash or other valuables. Burying money and fleeing would have been a practical response, especially if returning later seemed possible. But history does not guarantee that return ever happened. A raid, arrest, violence, or sudden change in circumstances could have left the hidden cache exactly where it was, while the people who knew its location disappeared.
The two Liberty dollars therefore become something different: not evidence of the treasure itself, but potential coordinates in a forgotten hiding system. If that interpretation is correct, the most valuable discovery may still be underground.
Did Josh Gates Find the First Point on a Buried Map?
The most explosive possibility is that the excavation has uncovered only the beginning of a much larger treasure trail. There is no proof that the coins were intentionally placed as markers, and there is no confirmed cache waiting nearby. But if the gang really needed to hide emergency money before the 1924 raid, deliberately placed markers would provide a plausible way to relocate it later without leaving an obvious written record.

That theory changes the meaning of the discovery completely. Two silver dollars would no longer be the final artifact from the Ashley Gang’s hidden economy. They would be the first clue in a chain that may lead toward money John Ashley never recovered. A marker system could have allowed the gang to conceal cash in multiple locations, using objects that looked ordinary enough to escape attention while preserving a memory of where the money was buried.
For Expedition Unknown, that is where the small discovery becomes enormous. Josh Gates may not have uncovered a forgotten fortune. He may have uncovered the point from which the search should begin.
Because two silver dollars are not much of a treasure.
But if they were deliberately buried…
They may be worth far more than their face value.
They may be the first coordinates to a fortune John Ashley left behind.






